Wednesday, October 09, 2024

Chicago Council of Lawyers finds 12 Cook County jurists Well Qualified for retention

The Chicago Council of Lawyers has released its Evalutaion Report for Cook County jurists seeking retention in the November 2024 General Eleciton. The second link in the preceding sentence will take you to the Council's complete report.

The Council has found 12 of the 78 Cook County jurists seeking retention to be "Well Qualified," the highest rating issued by the Council for this retention election. In this post, we look at what the Council had to say about the one Appellate Court justice and the 11 Circuit Court judges (though one of these is currently serving on the Appellate Court) who received the Council's Well Qualified rating.

The Council also found four Circuit Court judges "Not Recommended" for retention. FWIW will look at those ratings in a different post.

The CCL's "Well Qualified" ratings for candidates on the 2024 retention ballot follow, in ballot order:
Hon. Thomas Hoffman

Hon. Thomas Hoffman was admitted to the Illinois bar in 1971. He was appointed to the Circuit Court in 1984 and elected in 1988. He was assigned to the Appellate Court, First District in 1993 and elected in 1994. He previously served in the Law Division. Prior to becoming a judge, he was an Assistant Corporation Counsel for the City of Chicago and was in private practice.

Justice Hoffman is well known for his intellect, preparation, and active participation from the bench. He is praised for having a strong command of the appellate record and applicable case law, while being willing to apply a common-sense approach when appropriate. Some interviewed reported a sometimes “gruff” demeanor characterized by very pointed questioning, while others described similar behavior as Justice Hoffman being “involved” or “incisive.”

The Council finds him Well Qualified for retention to the Appellate Court.

Hon. Stuart Fredric Lubin

Hon. Stuart Fredric Lubin was admitted to the Illinois bar in 1974. He was appointed in 1991 and elected in 1994. Since 1991, he has been assigned to the Juvenile Justice Division and previously served in the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, Stuart Lubin was a career Assistant Cook County Public Defender.

Judge Lubin is regarded as an excellent jurist with very good legal ability. He is praised for his courtroom management skills, efficiently running court calls. He is reported to have a good temperament and to be helpful, patient, and respectful of all parties. He is praised for his integrity and impartiality.

The Council finds him Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Carol M. Howard

Hon. Carol Howard was admitted to the Illinois bar in 1986. Judge Howard was elected in 2006 and, since 2009, has been assigned to the Criminal Division. Previously, she was assigned to the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, she was an Assistant Cook County Public Defender.

Respondents were overwhelmingly positive in their assessment of Judge Howard’s legal ability, demeanor, and integrity. She is described as respectful and professional, even in “chaotic environments.” Judge Howard is considered well-prepared, capable, and effective on the bench.

The Council finds her Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Regina Scannicchio

Hon. Regina Scannicchio was admitted to the Illinois bar in 1989. She was elected to the bench in 2012, and, since 2022, has been Presiding Judge of the Domestic Relations Division, where she was previously assigned. Prior to becoming a judge, she was in private practice.

Judge Scannicchio is considered a dedicated and knowledgeable jurist, with an excellent courtroom demeanor. She is described as approachable and engaged as Presiding judge, as well as fair and considerate in court.

The Council finds her Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Aicha Marie MacCarthy

Hon. Aicha Marie MacCarthy was admitted to the Illinois bar in 1997. She was elected to the bench in 2012 and, since 2013, has been assigned to the Probate Division. Previously, she served in the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, she was a solo practitioner and worked in government, at the Chicago Housing Authority and at the Chicago Department of Law.

Judge MacCarthy is considered to have excellent legal knowledge and ability. She is well-prepared and respected for direct and clear decisions. The issues in her courtroom can be complex and emotionally difficult, but she is adept at handling sensitive situations and known for treating everyone patiently, fairly, and with respect.

The Council finds her Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Michael T. Mullen

Hon. Michael T. Mullen was admitted to the Illinois bar in 1981. He was elected in 2012 and, since 2013, has been assigned to the Chancery Division. Previously, he served in the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, he was in private practice and had served as a U.S. Attorney and in the Illinois Attorney General's Office.

Judge Mullen is described as a smart, kind, and well-organized judge. He is even-tempered and conducts his courtroom with patience and preparation. He is reported to be sensitive to issues of bias and good at maintaining order in his courtroom without losing his patience or becoming unkind. Feedback on Judge Mullen is uniformly positive.

The Council finds him Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Kent Delgado

Hon. Kent Delgado was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1996. He was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2017 and elected in 2018. He is assigned to the Probate Division and previously served in the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, he was a solo practitioner and an Assistant State’s Attorney in Cook County.

Judge Delgado is generally described as knowledgeable in probate law. He is considered level-headed and respectful in the courtroom. Respondents noted his diligence, stating that he always provides the legal basis for his decision. He is described as always punctual, prepared, well-versed in the law and of optimal temperament. The steps he took during the first months of the pandemic and shutdown are said to exemplify his dedication to his duties, but also to the needs of the litigants.

The Council finds Judge Delgado Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. David R. Navarro

Hon. David R. Navarro was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1993. He was appointed to the Appellate Court, First District, in 2023. He was previously appointed to the Circuit Court in 2017 and elected in 2018. Prior to becoming a judge, he served in the Illinois Attorney General’s Office, as an Assistant State’s Attorney, and a Special Assistant U.S. Attorney.

Justice Navarro is reported to be a fair and knowledgeable judge. He is considered to have a fair and balanced approach, ensuring all parties receive equal treatment under the law. We note that he is being evaluated for retention to the Circuit Court, the position to which he was elected, and not the Appellate Court to which he is presently assigned.

The Council finds him Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Tiana Ellis Blakely

Hon. Tiana Ellis Blakely was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 2004. She was elected in 2018 and has served in the Sixth Municipal District in Markham since that election. Prior to becoming a judge, she worked as an Assistant Public Defender in Cook County.

Judge Blakely is widely regarded as an excellent criminal judge by both state's attorneys and defense attorneys. She is considered fair and respectful with a balanced approach. She receives praise for her courtroom management with regard to both efficiency and impartiality.

The Council finds her Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Scott D. McKenna

Hon. Scott D. McKenna was admitted to the bar in 1996. He was elected in 2018 and, since 2023, has been assigned to the Law Division. Previously, he served in the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, he was in private practice.

Judge McKenna is generally well-regarded as a professional, ethical judge, who runs a courteous, well-managed courtroom. He is prepared, knowledgeable and effective. Many respondents consider him to be “one of the best.” Overall, respondents offered high praise for this judge in all aspects of judicial qualifications.

The Council finds him Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Erika Lynn Orr

Erika Lynn Orr was admitted to practice in 1998. She was elected in 2018 and has been assigned to the Domestic Relations Division in the Sixth Municipal District in Markham. Prior to becoming a judge, she was a solo practitioner.

Judge Orr is consistently described as knowledgeable about the law and consistent in applying the law to facts before her. Many respondents note that her background in finance serves her well in domestic relations. She is praised for her sensitivity to cultural issues that arise in family matters and ensures self-represented litigants in her courtroom understand the process without ever crossing into legal advice or advocacy. She is considered to have the highest integrity and to be diplomatic, sometimes stern, but always patient and fair.

The Council finds her Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Hon. Athanasios (Tom) S. Sianis

Hon. Athanasios (Tom) S. Sianis was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 2004. He was elected in 2018, and, since 2021, he has been Supervising Judge of the Traffic Division and previously served in the First Municipal District. Prior to becoming a judge, he was a Special Assistant Attorney General and an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney.

Judge Sianis is very well respected by his colleagues and attorneys. He appears to value ongoing education, not simply in case law, but also in case management, diversity, and access to justice.

His rulings are characterized as fair and well-reasoned, and he is described as both patient and exemplary. Respondents remarked that he takes his role as judge seriously and is an excellent judge.

The Council finds him Well Qualified for retention to the Circuit Court.

Tuesday, October 08, 2024

Girl, I Guess weighs in on the judicial retention ballot

The Girl I Guess 2024 Progressive Voter Guide is out now (the first link here is to the Girl, I Guess website; the second is to the Google Doc that is the guide), urging voters to vote against the retention of 16 of the 78 jurists on this fall's Cook County judicial retention ballot. Here is a screengrab of the Girl, I Guess retention recommendations:
The reader will observe that four of these 16 negative recommendations are not just a "no" but a "super no."

Just an aside to the voting public: There is no "super no" option on the actual retention ballot -- even if you vote by mail.

However, the authors of the Girl, I Guess Guide do offer explanations for their "super no" recommendations, and only for these highly negative exhortations, and we will come to these in a moment.

First, though, for those who may not be familiar with this increasingly influential online publication, let me quote from the authors' description of the guide (emphasis in original):
Girl, I Guess is Jewish, Black, queer, trans, nerdy and dedicated to helping members of our community navigate a confusing ballot and identify the most progressive candidates. We also recommend you consult with progressive / radical organizers in your community, especially queer, trans, Black, and Brown folks!
The authors of the guide are Stephanie Skora, "a grouchy Jewish trans dyke, and an anarchist with a political science degree," and Raeghn Draper, "a pro-labor, queer, Black, non-binary babe who is bisexual only because they like the flag colors better than the ones for the pansexual flag." While both are involved with every race and endorsement covered in the guide, they have divided the coverage up and written separately about specific races. For example, Skora apparently prepared each of the "super no" explanations.

The Girl, I Guess Guide's retention coverage starts at p. 55 (of 65). It begins by throwing a bouquet in the direction of the Injustice Watch Judicial Voter Guide.

The Girl, I Guess guide does more than simply praise the "snappy coverage" of Injustice Watch; it clearly relies on it as well: Every judge with a "notable controversy" cited in the Injustice Watch guide received a negative recommendation from Girl, I Guess guide, including all four of the judges receiving a "super no."

But Girl, I Guess also recommends "no" votes on several judges who did not have 'notable controversies' according to Injustice Watch. Girl, I Guess offers four additional criteria by which it makes recommendations in judicial races (pp. 65-66):
  1. Are you a cop?
  2. Are you sketchy, suspicious, or have you done bad/controversial things in the past?
  3. Are you a dumbass?
  4. Do Bar Associations think that you’re qualified?
Bar ratings are only now starting to come out. The Chicago Bar Association ratings just came out last week; the Chicago Council of Lawyers released their ratings tonight (story to come). The Girl, I Guess Google doc may yet be amended as ratings trickle in.

With that caveat, here is what the Girl, I Guess guide says with regard to its "super no" statements (pp. 56-57) (links and emphases as in original):
E. Kenneth Wright, Jr.
The Dish:

Wright, Jr, who is 83 years old and running for retention for another 6-year term is unfortunately also a shady and unscrupulous character. He’s one of two Judges who was caught by the crack reporting team at Injustice Watch as claiming a Homestead Exemption on his property taxes outside of Cook County. For those of you, dear reader, who are not in the know about the ins and outs of Cook County property tax exemptions, a Homestead Exemption is the most common kind of homeowner tax exemption taken in Illinois, usable only on the owner’s principal dwelling place, meaning the place that they live the majority of the time. Wright, Jr. has claimed a homestead exemption on a property in Joliet (which sits in Will County) since 1978, and a Senior Homestead Exemption since 2018. Whoopsie! Illinois state law requires judges to live in the District that they represent, which Wright Jr. clearly does not. Vote NO on this judge who has been lying to Cook County voters for the 30 years that he’s been on the bench.

Mary Margaret Brosnahan
The Dish:

Brosnahan is a complete non-starter for Girl, I Guess for violating three of our four Judicial Evaluation Criteria (Bar Association Ratings pending for the fourth!) by being married to a cop with 43 allegations against him who’s already cost the City $9 million in misconduct settlements. Eww. She’s also had two murder cases reversed and determined unfair due to the “cumulative effect” of Brosnahan’s errors which impacted the “trustworthiness of the judicial process,” which sounds both sketchy and dumb to me. Vote NO on Brosnahan.

Maura Slattery Boyle
The Dish:

Slattery Boyle is a machine nepo baby, and was sent to the bench in 2000 on the back of a Daley endorsement. Bridgeport, am I right? Her rulings have been reversed at least 46 times during her tenure, she and her husband apparently don’t pay their taxes, and the City has sued her several times over building code violations. Whoof. Slattery Boyle barely won retention last time we covered her in 2018, and we’ve gotta hope that she doesn’t make it this time because Cook County has had quite enough of her. Vote NO.

Shannon O'Malley
The Dish:

O’Malley may not be a Libertarian (as far as we know), but he’s going to be this year’s Silly Name Caucus inductee for nomenclature-related shenanigans that loyal Girl, I Guess readers haven’t seen since the days of Benjamin Adam Winderweedle. According to Injustice Watch, O’Malley changed his name and party in 2018 (after running unsuccessfully for judge in two different Counties and Cook County State’s Attorney in 2004) to Shannon O’Malley from Phillip Spiwak. He claimed it was to honor a recently-passed mentor, but observers and reporters agreed that it was a naked attempt to improve his electoral chances, as it’s a well-known fact that Irish names do better on Cook County Judicial ballots, albeit only slightly. Well, apparently, it worked! O’Malley was elected in 2018 in his first electoral attempt since his name change. This would be just dumb and funny enough to maybe slide by with a disgruntled YES, but O’Malley unfortunately is also the second judges to find himself on the wrong side of the “she doesn’t even go here” scandal, with property tax exemption records also listing a Homestead Exemption for him in Will County. O’Malley claims that his wife lives in Will County by herself while he lives in Schaumburg, but… come on, man. It’s a judge’s duty to avoid even the appearance of impropriety, and this doesn’t pass the sniff test.

On top of all of this, I had multiple attorneys reach out to me who have tried cases in front of O’Malley, questioning in several ways his command of the law as it relates to Child Protection and Family Law cases, and noting his poor temperament in the courtroom. Vote NO.
Most of the above links in the Girl, I Guess narratives are to Injustice Watch, the Sun-Times, or the Tribune. But, with regard to Judge Slattery Boyle, there is also link to an ISBA News article from 2012. Slattery Boyle was comfortably retained in that election, as the linked story confirms, but, as Skora states, Slattery Boyle did have a fairly close call in 2018.

Although Girl, I Guess does not explain its other "no" recommendations, the bases of at least a few of these be reasonably determined without resorting to speculation. For example, Judge Colleen Reardon Daly is married to an ex-Chicago Police lieutenant, , according to Injustice Watch. That is obviously a major problem for Girl, I Guess.

Injustice Watch noted that Judge Michael Tully Mullen "ruled that police officers could have serious disciplinary cases heard by arbitrators instead of the Chicago Police Board," a very unpopular ruling among anti-police activists. Non-lawyers (and the authors of the Girl, I Guess guide are not lawyers) may not always fully appreciate that judicial ethics require judges to follow the law without regard to "public clamor or fear of criticism" and "without regard to whether the judge approves or disapproves of the law in question."

Given the "super no" recommendations given to two judges whose current residence is apparently in question, the reason behind the negative recommendation on Judge Beatriz Santiago is likewise apparent: Judge Santiago was accused of putting a mortgage on a home that she owned, outside the 6th Subcircuit from which she'd only just been elected, and claiming, in the mortgage documents, that this home was her principal residence. If that home actually was her principal residence at the time she applied for the mortgage, she might have been removed from office. As it was, the Courts Commission chose merely to censure her. (FWIW analysis of the Courts Commission's 2016 decision in Judge Santiago's case is here.)

Friday, October 04, 2024

Advocates Society recommends 40 Cook County Circuit Court judges for retention

Updated 10/5/24

The Advocates Society has released a list of 40 Cook County Circuit Court judges and one McHenry County judge that it recommends for retention on the November ballot. The announcemet is reproduced above. The McHenry County judge is 22nd Circuit Chief Judge Michael J. Chmiel. The 40 Cook County judges are:
  1. Ronald Bartkowicz
  2. Mary Brosnahan
  3. Joel Chupack
  4. H. Yvonne Coleman
  5. Adrienne Davis
  6. Daniel Degnan
  7. Kent Delgado
  8. John Ehrlich
  9. Ellen Flannigan
  10. Peter Gonzalez
  11. Ieshia Gray
  12. Jack Hagerty
  13. Robert Harris
  14. Lindsay Huge
  15. Lionel Jean-Baptiste
  16. Preston Jones, Jr.
  17. Martin Kelley
  18. Kathaleen Lanahan
  19. Stuart Lubin
  20. Lisa Ann Marino
  21. Diann Marsalek
  22. Thomas McGuire
  23. Scott D. McKenna
  24. Michael T. Mullen
  25. Shannon P. O'Malley
  26. Erika Orr
  27. Linda Perez
  28. Marian Perkins
  29. Clare J. Quish
  30. Joanne Rosado
  31. Stephanie Saltouros
  32. Beatriz Santiago
  33. Debra Seaton
  34. James Shapiro
  35. Tom Sianis
  36. Rosa Maria Silva
  37. Maura Slattery Boyle
  38. James Varga
  39. Andrea Webber
  40. Jeanne Wrenn

Tickets available for October 18 Illinois Bar Foundation Gala

The Illinois Bar Foundation will hold its 2024 Gala on Friday, October 18, at the Old Post Office, 433 W. Van Buren. This black tie event will begin with a VIP reception at 6:00 p.m.; a general reception will follow at 6:30 p.m. A full seated dinner and program will follow the receptions, with live and silent auctions, dancing, and cocktails.

At the program, the IBF will bestow its Distinguished Award for Excellence on Jay Edelson of Edelson PC, saluting his "leadership in the Illinois legal and philanthropic communities coupled with his dedication to serving others through the practice of law." In addition, event organizers promise "a little whimsy."

Tickets for the event are $500 apiece, although discounted tickets (for $400 each) are available for nonprofit and government attorneys and judges. Complimentary valet parking and coat check are avaialble, but these tickets do not include admission to the VIP reception.

Event tickets that include admission to the VIP reception are $1,000 each.

Sponsorships are also available (Benefactor - $10,000, Gala Partner - $25,000, Gala Cornerstone - $50,000, Presenting Sponsor - $75,000). Each increasing level of sponsorship comes with increasing perks and numbers of VIP tickets. For a complete list of all available sponsorships, or to simply order tickets, click on this page of the IBF website. While the physical program book is already at the printer's, there are still opportunities to be included in the digital program book.

In addition, the IBF is hosting a raffle offering a five-night stay for two to the winner's choice of Tuscany, Bali, Thailand, Paris, or Greece. For more information about the raffle, visit this page of the IBF website. Questions about the Gala may be directed to Jessie Reeves, Director of Events & Administration, at jreeves@illinoisbarfoundation.org.

October 24 fundraiser for Judge de Castro

It wasn't supposed to be this way. Pablo de Castro won his Democratic primary race this past March and then, in April, since he (and all countywide Cook County judicial candidates) had no Republican opposition, the Illinois Supreme Court gave de Castro an early start on his judicial career.

Now, however, de Castro finds that he is not unopposed after all.

Thus, Judge de Castro's supporters are planning a fundraiser for his fall campaign. The event is set for Thursday, October 24, starting at 7:00 p.m., at Sketchbook Brewing Co., 4901 Main St., Skokie. Jazz singer and songwriter Kurt Elling will perform.

Tickets are $150 each. Sponsorships are available (Friend - $250, Supporter - $500, Host - $1,000). Tickets are available at this DemocracyEngine link on the candidate's website. And, who knows? Perhaps that QR code in the graphic above may also do something, for those who know how to work such things....

Probate Division update: Docket books out, screens and keyboards in

A note and an accompanying photo from the Chief Judge's Office:
Cook County Chief Judge Timothy C. Evans met with Probate judges and staff on Friday, September 27 to celebrate the opening of new Probate Division Courtroom 1813. This new courtroom replaces the antiquated docket room and is updated with high tech equipment which will improve access to justice for lawyers and litigants. As of October 1, 2024, cases assigned to guardianship of minors' estates Calendar 1, are being heard in the new courtroom by Judge Daniel R. Degnan. Pictured are Judge Terrence J. McGuire, Chief Judge Evans, Judge Degnan (seated), Presiding Judge Daniel B. Malone, Judge Susan Kennedy-Sullivan, and Judge Amee Alonso.
I wonder if there are any docket books left in the Daley Center; this may be the finish. When I started out, there were docket books in every division. Unlike a lot of court files, the old books were too big and heavy to grow legs and walk away. The status of any given case could be ascertained, even if the file jacket was missing. Or, and this sometimes proved to be the case, the file was not missing, but actually accounted for, only in another location, such as a courtroom.

Technology is great -- you're reading this, aren't you? -- but it is subject to hacking by enemies foreign and domestic, sunspots, power outages, and (perhaps, someday) control of all those AI entities we're so heedlessly setting up and letting loose. Is there no one left who saw James T. Kirk or Dr. Who fight existential battles with megalomaniacal machines? Those old TV shows were warnings, people....

Thursday, October 03, 2024

Seventy-seven of 78 Cook County jurists recommended for retention by the Chicago Bar Association

Updated 10/4/24 after CBA's release of explanation for its recommendation regarding Judge Marino

The Chicago Bar Association released its "Judge Smart" Guide for the upcoming election.

The headline here has the main story: The CBA has recommended retention for 77 of the 78 Cook County jurists seeking new terms. That number includes both of the Appellate Court justices seeking retention, as well as 75 out of the 76 Circuit Court judges seeking new six-year terms. The only judge not recommended for retention was Judge Lisa Ann Marino.

The CBA JEC has released the following explanation of its rating regarding Judge Marino:
Judge Lisa Marino has been found “Not Recommended” for retention as a Circuit Court. Judge Marino was admitted to practice in 1988 and was elected as a judge in 2012. She has been sitting in the First Municipal District, Housing Section, since 2016. Significant concerns about Judge Marino’s knowledge of the law, temperament, and diligence resulted in the “Not Recommended” finding.
The CBA did not recommend Marino for retention in 2018; as in 2024, in 2018 Marino was the only retention judge receiving a 'not recommended' rating from the CBA. Marino's biography on the Cook County Retention Judges website correctly notes that the CBA did rate Marino qualified when she was elected to the bench in 2012.

The CBA no longer explains its reasons for rating retention judges qualified.

The CBA "Judge Smart" Guide also discloses the CBA's rating for Republican countywide candidate Tien H. Glaub. (Glaub was not a candidate in the Republican primary and was not therefore not evaluated at that time.) But Glaub did file for associate judge in 2021, and the CBA did issue an unfavorable rating then. That rating was not changed for this election:
Pursuant to section 34, rule 27.4 of The Chicago Bar Association’s Judicial Evaluation Committee’s Governing Resolution, The Executive Committee has voted that Tien H. Glaub’s prior finding of NOT RECOMMENDED shall stand.
FWIW has not yet done an Organizing the Data post on the now-contested countywide Flannery vacancy, pending the release of all bar evaluations of Glaub's candidacy.

Voters can read the CBA's evaluations for all candidates on the November ballot, but with the exception of the race for the Flannery vacancy and four suburban subcircuit races, all judicial elections on the November ballot in Cook County are uncontested.

FWIW has published Organizing the Data posts in those four subcircuit races. These posts contain the CBA's explanation of its ratings of the competing candidates. These posts may be found at these links:

Tuesday, October 01, 2024

Appellate Lawyers Association needs sponsors, judges for November Moot Court competition

The Appellate Lawyers Association is looking for judges and sponsors for its annual Hudson Memorial Moot Court Competition, to be held November 1 and 2. The Friday, November 1 sessions will be held at DePaul University College of Law, while the Saturday, November 2 sessions will be conducted at the Daley Center.

Non-ALA members are welcome to serve as judges or brief graders.

Or sponsors.

Or all of the above. Actually, the ALA would be probably be pleased as punch were you to volunteer to judge and write a check as a sponsor.

There will be three sessions for the tournament's November 1 first round, at 9:30 a.m., noon, and 3:30 p.m. Thirty-four judges are needed for each session. Ten judges will also be needed for the quarterfinal round of the competition, on November 2, at 9:30 a.m. (Actual Appellate Court Justices will judge the semi-final and final rounds.)

The ALA will also need 34 brief graders.

To volunteer for one of these slots, click on this page of the ALA website and follow the applicable link.

Judges will receive CLE credit for their service. The Supreme Court Rules do not permit graders to receive CLE credit. (Personally, this seems backward to me: Grading the briefs seems at least as credit-worthy as serving as a judge at one of these compensations -- but, to date, the Supreme Court has not solicited my views on the subject.)

Now... about those sponsorship opportunities.... The ALA is offering four levels of sponsorship (Bronze - $250, Silver - $500, Gold - $750, and Platinum - $1,000). Only two Platinum sponsorships are available.

The benefits appertaining to each level of sponsorship may be found by following the applicable links from this page of the ALA website. Yes, it's the same page as the one linked above. But you are clicking to a different link from this page.

Unless, of course, you offer to both judge and sponsor. Which, as noted, the ALA would like very much....

Friday, September 27, 2024

LAP Awards Dinner set for October 10 at Brookfield Zoo

The Illinois Lawyers Assistance Program will hold its annual Awards Dinner on Thursday, October 10, from 5:00 to 8:00 p.m., at the Brookfield Zoo. Registration for the event closes a week from today, on October 4.

Tickets for the event are $150 apiece, and are available from this Eventbrite link. Sponsorships are available (Friends of LAP - $250, Bronze - $500, Silver - $1,000, Gold - $2,500, Platinum - $3,500, or Presenting - $5,000). Each sponsorship level has an increasing number of perks, including numbers of event tickets, social media mentions, or recognition during the event itself. Presenting sponsors will be invited to address the gathering. In addition, LAP is seeking beverage and music sponsors, for $1,500 each. These last are exclusive sponsorships and may not be available long. Information regarding each level of sponsorship can be found, and donations of any amount can be made, at this Eventbrite link.

Ticketholders will be admitted to the zoo beginning at 3:00 p.m. They will thus have the opportunity to see for themselves, prior to the start of the scheduled program, whether something's happening at the zoo. (Personally, I do believe it, I do believe it's true.)

According to the Illinois Courts website, First District Appellate Justice Jesse G. Reyes will be the honored guest and speaker at this event. LAP will present these awards at the October 10 awards dinner:
  • Michael J. Howlett Jr. Award - Lester Munson
    Awarded to an individal in recognition of their promotion of the goals and missions of LAP within the legal community.

  • Hon. John Powers Crowley Award - Cook County Chief Judge Timothy C. Evans
    Awarded to a member of the judiciary who has contributed to the goals and mission of LAP; a special honor, awarded as warranted.

  • Carl H. Rolewick Award - Matthew S. Sims
    Awarded to an attorney who has contributed to the goals and mission of LAP.

  • Executive Director Award - Roueen Rafeyan, M.D.
    Awarded to an individual or organization that the Executive Director feels has supported her in her work at LAP.

  • Daneen Fitzpatrick Berres Award - Lisa G. Williams
    Awarded to a member of the LAP Women's group who has contributed to the goals and mission of LAP, and who has demonstrated a commitment to helping other women in the group by acting as a role mode and peer support person.
Silent auction and raffle items are are also needed. Contact cramski@illinoislap.org to arrange for auction donations.

Because service in the Illinois General Assembly did not come with enough perks already....

Reminiscent of the late Sydney J. Harris, here's a thing I learned en route to looking up other things....

Effective January 1, 2025, the Illinois Supreme Court has amended Supreme Court Rule 795 (CLE accreditation standards and hours), by adding a new subsection (d)(13), which provides:
Service as Elected or Appointed Member of the Illinois General Assembly. An attorney elected or appointed to the Illinois General Assembly earns three hours of general MCLE credit by attending at least one day of one qualifying legislative session. A "qualifying legislative session" is any official regular, special, or veto session of the Illinois General Assembly for which the member is present in the Illinois House of Representatives or Illinois Senate chambers or any official committee or subcommittee meeting of the Illinois House of Representatives or Illinois Senate for which the representative or senator is present. Credit for this attendance is limited to 3 hours for each qualifying legislative session and is capped at 12 hours in each two-year reporting period. There is no carryover of these credits to another two-year reporting period and no professional responsibility credit is available. The attorney must report the credit earned from this activity to the MCLE Board using the Board's online submission process no later than the reporting deadline for the reporting period in which the attorney earned the credit. Newly admitted attorneys do not earn Illinois MCLE credit under this provision.
It's not a complete get-out-of-CLE-free pass for lawyer-legislators: Hauling one's carcass down to Springfield and staying the day provides only a maximum of 12 of the required 30 CLE hours in any one reporting period (and only three in any given session) -- and the honorable member must still enter his or her attendance in the now-usual online manner (the dozen hours are not assumed or automatically conferred). Moreover, these are general credits only, meaning attendance doesn't count toward the various professional resopnsibility hours requirements.

Still... was there really a burning need for this? Were significant numbers of lawyer-legislators working so diligently on the people's business that they were failing to attend to their own CLE requirements? One guesses that Someone Important must have asked for this... but FWIW does not have the investigative resources to find out who that Someone Important might be.

Local Federal Courts again sponsor Bill of Rights Day contest

Like me, perhaps, some of you are still a bit giddy from your recent Constitution Day celebrations.

So be it. The Constitutional calendar moves on.

And, as we approach this year's Bill of Rights Day (December 15, for those of you who may have forgotten), the United States Courts of Appeals along with the United States District Courts in the Seventh and Eighth Circuits, are hosting the fifth annual Bill of Rights Day contest for students in grades 5 to 12 in Illinois (and elsewhere in the 7th and 8th Circuits). The contest is being conducted under the auspices of the Judicial Learning Center.

While there are (presumably) very few middle school and high school students among FWIW's regular readers, a great many FWIW readers have children or grandchildren who do fall in the target demographic. Some of us have middle school or high school teachers in our families, and among our friends and neighbors, as well. So we can alert them.

Pass the word to your kids, grandkids, friends, and family as follows:
Students in grades 5-12 from Arkansas, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Wisconsin are encouraged to submit art and essays on the importance of the Bill of Rights. Creativity is encouraged.

A grand prize winner from each grade level category will be awarded a $500 cash prize, be able to take part in a virtual event on Wednesday, December 4 with Federal Judges and other legal experts on the enduring rights afforded to Americans by the Bill of Rights, and have their name and submission shared on the websites of the participating United States District Courts. Finalists from each grade level category will receive a $50 prize.

There are four grade level categories: Grade 5-6, Grades 7-8, Grades 9-10, Grades 11-12.

Submissions will be accepted during the fall semester, through 5:00 p.m. on Friday, November 1, 2024.

Finalists will be notified by Thanksgiving and grand prize winners will be announced at the virtual event on December 4. A finalist must be present to win the grand prize.

Detailed contest prompts, guidelines, and online submission form can be found here: JudicialLearningCenter.org/bill-of-rights-day.

Teachers: Be sure to tell your students to list you on their submission forms. All teacher names submitted will be entered into a raffle for valuable gift cards. The more students you have enter the more chances you have to win.

Please also note: There is a bulk-submit option for teachers. Contact the Judicial Learning Center through the website for instructions on how to submit for your entire class. Teachers are strongly encouraged to use the bulk-submit option if multiple students are entering.
Persons not entering the contest who may nonetheless have a rooting interest in the proceedings are welcome to attend the virtual event on December 4 at 6:00 p.m. Central/7:00 p.m. Eastern. Attendees will also have the opportunity to win prizes.

Event registration is required. To register, click JudicialLearningCenter.org/bill-of-rights-day.

Thursday, September 26, 2024

CBA issues updated ratings for 12th Subcircuit candidates

FWIW has confirmed this morning that the Chicago Bar Association has found 12th Subcircuit candidate Pamela Curran Smith (pictured at left) "Qualified" in her bid for the Quinn vacancy.

My earlier post profiling the Quinn vacancy has been updated accordingly.

Readers scrolling to the comments in the linked post will see that that candidate called me out for publishing the CBA's "not recommended" rating; she expressly denied that she "declined to participate" in the CBA's screening process. I had relied on the rating issued with the CBA's Voters' Guide for the March 2024 primary in preparing my post.

In my experience, bar ratings, once issued (and once the regular appeal process has been exhausted), do not change between the primary and general elections. I can recall an instance where a candidate rating was withdrawn (only to be reinstated later) -- but, until now, I can not recall a single instance where this kind of change has occurred.

The operative words in the preceding sentence are "until now."

In the course of investigating the question this morning I learned, from a reliable CBA source, that there were a few candidates who received "Not Recommended" ratings during the primary season because "we did not receive their completed questionnaires in time to conduct an investigation. Part of this turned out to not be completely their fault and we decided in all fairness to allow them to submit their questionnaires and go through our process."

Ms. Smith was one of the candidates who was allowed to proceed with the screening process after this determination was made.

The CBA also today provided FWIW with an updated "Qualified" letter to 12th Subcircuit candidate Alon Stein (Dickler vacancy). He was rated "Qualfied" for the primary as well, and, as I had done with Ms. Smith, I had used the language from the CBA's primary voters' guide in my Organizing the Data post. However, since the language of the CBA's explanation of its rating has changed, I have updated that post as well, to reflect the CBA's current language.

Finally, the CBA has advised FWIW that its general election voters guide (the Smart Guide) should be available soon. FWIW will have that guide when available.

Tuesday, September 24, 2024

Organizing the Data: 18th Subcircuit - Converted from Associate Judgeship of Linn

There are only five judicial vacancies on the Cook County ballot this November in which voters have any choice whatsoever. All of the other races were decided in the March Democratic primary. One of these contested races is in the new northwest suburban 18th Subcircuit. This post looks at the candidates for that vacancy.

Candidates are listed in punch number order. This year, that means the Democratic candidate is listed before the Republican candidate.

This post may be updated with new, additional, or corrected information, as it becomes available.

One final note: Each candidate may have endorsements from persons or groups not shown below. These are typically found on the candidate's websites. FWIW only publishes endorsements that it can independently verify.


John Hock - #92

Campaign Website

John Hock: In his own words

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
John Hock is "Qualified" for the office of Circuit Judge. Mr. Hock was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2009. He is an Assistant State's Attorney for Cook County currently working on post-conviction matters. He previously served as a public defender. Mr. Hock is well regarded by his peers and judges before whom he has appeared for his even temperament, integrity, and work ethic.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
John Hock was admitted to the Florida bar in 2007. He has been with the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office since 2022 and is assigned to the Special Litigation Unit where he manages a caseload of serious felony cases. He did civil litigation in Florida from 2007 to 2009. He then worked until 2011 for the Will County Public Defender’s Office. From 2011 to 2013, he worked for a private law firm doing civil litigation, and from 2013 to 2022 he worked for the Lake County Public Defender’s Office. He is considered to have good legal ability. He has substantial litigation experience in both civil and criminal law matters. He is reported to have a good temperament. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Mr. John Hock was admitted to the Illinois bar in 2009 and was admitted to practice in Florida in 2007. He was employed with a civil litigation firm in Florida until 2009, when he obtained his Illinois license and started with the Will County Public Defender. After working for Cremer Law focusing on commercial and international litigation for two years, he spent nine years with the Lake County Public Defender. Since 2022 he has been an assistant state’s attorney with Cook County, focusing on post-conviction matters in the Special Litigation Unit. He has been a presenter on legal topics and a committee member for the Northwest Suburban Bar Association.

Attorneys consider him to be an expert in his field of prisoner petitions. He handles all cases without bias, follows the law, and is diligent in his work. ISBA finds John Hock qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Not Evaluated (through no fault of candidate)

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Endorsements
Chicago Federation of Labor
International Union of Operating Engineers Local 399
Teamsters Joint Council No. 25
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 134
Teamsters Local 700
------------------------------------------------------

Lynn Terese Palac - #93


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
Lynn Palac is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Palac was admitted to practice law in 1999. Ms. Palac has been practicing law in Cook County for 25 years and has significant litigation and trial experience, primarily in criminal cases. Ms. Palac is well regarded by judges and opposing attorneys for her legal knowledge, pleasant demeanor, and work ethic. She is also praised for her community involvement.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Lynn T. Palac was admitted to practice in 1999 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 10 years before she left that office to do criminal defense work. She also is employed by Catholic Charities where she provides training in domestic violence and domestic relations cases.

Lynn T. Palec is considered to have good legal ability and temperament. She is praised for her litigation skills. The Council finds her Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Ms. Lynn Terese Palac has been licensed since 1999. After spending ten years as an Assistant State’s Attorney, she worked with several firms focusing on criminal, traffic and family law, before opening her own practice in 2015. She is also a Supervising Attorney for Catholic Charities Legal Assistance, where she trains other attorneys and represents clients of Catholic Charities, mostly in the domestic violence area. She is a member of several bar associations and has been Chair of the Northwest Suburban Bar Criminal Law Committee.

While attorneys considered her to be fair, punctual and a hard worker, concerns were raised about the depth and breadth of her litigation experience since leaving the State’s Attorney’s Office in 2009. ISBA finds Lynn T. Palac not qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Organizing the Data: 12th Subcircuit - Schleifer vacancy

There are only five judicial vacancies on the Cook County ballot this November in which voters have any choice whatsoever. All of the other races were decided in the March Democratic primary. Three of these contested races are in the north suburban 12th Subcircuit. This post looks at the candidates for the Schleifer vacancy in that 12th Subcircuit.

Candidates are listed in punch number order. This year, that means the Democratic candidate is listed before the Republican candidate.

This post may be updated with new, additional, or corrected information, as it becomes available.

One final note: Each candidate may have endorsements from persons or groups not shown below. These are typically found on the candidate's websites. FWIW only publishes endorsements that it can independently verify.


James "Jack" Costello - #95


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
James "Jack" Costello is "Qualified" to serve as a Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Costello was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2007 and has been an Assistant Cook County State's Attorney since that time. Mr. Costello has significant trial experience and is well-regarded for his diligence, legal ability and experience, and excellent demeanor.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
James Costello was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 2007. He has spent his career as an Assistant State’s Attorney in the Cook County State’s Attorney Office, where since 2019 he has served in the Special Prosecutions Bureau, Public Corruption and Financial Crimes Unit (he is currently First Chair). He has also served in the Felony Trial Division (2016-2019), the Felony Review and Preliminary Hearings Unit (2013-2016), the Misdemeanors/Traffic/Preliminary Hearings Units at the Markham courthouse (2009-2013), and Criminal Appeals in the Daley Center (2007-2009).

Mr. Costello is considered to have good legal ability and is especially praised for his temperament. He is reported to be knowledgeable and fair with lawyers and litigants. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Mr. James Costello has been licensed since 2007. He is a career prosecutor currently assigned to the Public Corruption/Financial Crimes Unit; before his assignment there in 2019, he worked in the Felony Trial Division, Misdemeanor/Traffic, and Appeals. He has been a speaker and guest lecturer at both law schools and high schools and coached mock trial teams. He is a board Member of the Arlington Heights Historical Society.

Mr. Costello has substantial jury and bench trial experience in criminal matters, including in complex cases. Attorneys praised his legal skills and ability, and analytical skills. He is reported to be high integrity, even keeled and fair. ISBA finds James Costello qualified for election to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Not Evaluated (through no fault of candidate)

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Endorsements
Chicago Federation of Labor
International Union of Operating Engineers Local 399
Teamsters Joint Council No. 25
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 134
Teamsters Local 700
------------------------------------------------------

Matthew Taylor - #96


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
Matthew Taylor is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Taylor was admitted to practice law in 2004. His practice includes criminal law, real estate law and estate planning. Although Mr. Taylor has been practicing law for 19 years, the scope of his practice and court experience is limited. At this point in his career, Mr. Taylor does not possess the requisite depth and breadth of legal experience to effectively serve as a judge.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Matthew Jay Taylor was admitted to practice in 2004 and has always practiced as a sole practitioner. He was a suburban police officer for 10 years prior to becoming a lawyer and currently works at the College of DuPage Suburban Law Enforcement Academy. He is the village prosecutor for 3 municipalities. His law practice includes real estate, probate, misdemeanor defense, child custody issues, and work in the Chancery Division of the Circuit Court.

Mr. Taylor is considered to have good legal ability and is reported to have good temperament. He is praised for his knowledge of the law and for always being prepared. He has substantial litigation experience in both civil and criminal law matters. He is a well respected practitioner. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Mr. Matthew Taylor has been licensed in Illinois since 2004. While he has always been a sole practitioner, focusing on misdemeanor criminal and traffic cases, estate and probate matters, and real estate matters, he was a full-time Palatine police officer until he retired from the department in 2017. He is currently the village prosecutor for Palatine and continues to teach at the Suburban Law Enforcement Academy. He has bench trial experience, mainly in municipal and misdemeanor matters, but no jury trials. He is a member of various bar associations and has been a coach for the York High School mock trial team, as well as being involved in other community and charitable activities.

Attorneys did report that he has good knowledge of the law and is considered to be sensitive to diversity with high character and integrity. Though concerns were raised over the depth and breadth of his entire legal experience, he is well respected by the judiciary, his peers and his opponents and is known for his handle situations with grace and decency. ISBA finds Matthew Taylor qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Not Evaluated (through no fault of the candidate)

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Not Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Not Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Not Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Organizing the Data: 12th Subcircuit - Quinn vacancy

Updated 10/15/24 to correct FWIW error on Frank Andreou's Decalogue rating
Updated 9/26/24 with corrected CBA rating on Pamela Curran Smith

There are only five judicial vacancies on the Cook County ballot this November in which voters have any choice whatsoever. All of the other races were decided in the March Democratic primary. Three of these contested races are in the north suburban 12th Subcircuit. This post looks at the candidates for the Quinn vacancy in that 12th Subcircuit.

Candidates are listed in punch number order. This year, that means the Democratic candidate is listed before the Republican candidate.

This post may be updated with new, additional, or corrected information, as it becomes available.

One final note: Each candidate may have endorsements from persons or groups not shown below. These are typically found on the candidate's websites. FWIW only publishes endorsements that it can independently verify.


Frank J. Andreou - #93


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
Pursuant to section 34 of The Chicago Bar Association’s Judicial Evaluation Committee’s Governing Resolution, The Executive Committee has voted to issue a “Qualified” rating for Frank J. Andreou’s current Circuit Court Judge candidacy.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Judge Frank Andreou was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1995. He currently presides over Calendar D (motion call) in the Law Division of the Cook County Circuit Court where he hears cases involving commercial litigation, medical and professional malpractice, toxic tort, product liability, auto liability, defamation, and other cases. He previously handled traffic and misdemeanor cases before moving to the Law Division. Prior being sworn in as an Associate Judge in January 2020, he worked in private practice for 20 years and for the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office from 1995-1999.

Judge Andreou is considered to have good legal ability and is praised for his ability to have a thorough grasp of the issues being argued before him. He is praised for his fairness and his professional temperament. He is also reported to be punctual and always prepared. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Hon. Frank J. Andreou has been licensed in Illinois since 1995. In December 2019 he was selected as an associate judge first sitting in the Traffic Division and the Second Municipal District (Skokie). Since July 2023 he has been assigned to the Law Division – Motion Section. Prior to his ascension to the bench, he had been in private practice both on his own and with a firm, with substantial jury, bench, and appellate experience. He is a board member for the Illinois Judges Association and the North Suburban Bar Association, and Second Vice President of the Hellenic Bar Association, as well as being a member of other bar associations. He has also served on the District 27 School Board.

Attorneys highly praised his legal knowledge and ability, stating that his rulings were well-reasoned and describing his grasp of fact and law as amazing. Additionally, they were all positive about his integrity, temperament, and diligence. ISBA finds Judge Frank J. Andreou highly qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Highly Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Highly Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Endorsements
Chicago Federation of Labor
International Union of Operating Engineers Local 399
Teamsters Joint Council No. 25
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 134
Teamsters Local 700
United Hellenic Voters of America
------------------------------------------------------

Pamela Curran Smith - #94


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
Pamela Curran Smith is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Smith was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2006. Ms. Smith is in private practice and has a wide range of practice experience. She is well-regarded for her legal experience and knowledge, high integrity, and good communication skills. Ms. Smith has the requisite experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Pamela Curran Smith was admitted to practice in 2006. She is a partner with a small law firm doing criminal defense and personal injury litigation. She has substantial litigation experience. She is considered to have good legal ability, and is praised for her litigation skills. She is reported to have a good temperament. The Council finds her Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Ms. Pamela Curran Smith has been licensed in Illinois since 2006. Since then, she has been employed, and is now a partner, at the Law Offices of Sam Amirante and Associates, with a focus on criminal defense, tort and civil litigation. She has limited criminal jury trial experience and substantial criminal bench trial experience, including in complex matters. She is a member of various bar associations and serves as a committee chair with the Northwest Suburban Bar Association.

Attorneys reported that she possesses a thorough understanding of the legal process and is always ready and prepared, also that she treats all with respect, is professional and has high integrity. ISBA finds Pamela Curran Smith qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Organizing the Data: 12th Subcircuit - Dickler vacancy

Updated 9/26/24 to reflect amended wording in CBA rating for Alon Stein

There are only five judicial vacancies on the Cook County ballot this November in which voters have any choice whatsoever. All of the other races were decided in the March Democratic primary. Three of these contested races are in the north suburban 12th Subcircuit. This post looks at the candidates for the Dickler vacancy in that 12th Subcircuit.

Candidates are listed in punch number order. This year, that means the Democratic candidate is listed before the Republican candidate.

This post may be updated with new, additional, or corrected information, as it becomes available.

One final note: Each candidate may have endorsements from persons or groups not shown below. These are typically found on the candidate's websites. FWIW only publishes endorsements that it can independently verify.


Alon Stein - #91


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
Alon Stein is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Stein was admitted to practice law in 2002 and is currently in private practice. He has experience in a wide variety of legal matters in numerous jurisdictions. The candidate is well-regarded for his significant trial experience, fine demeanor and excellent temperament.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Alon Stein was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 2002. Since 2013, he has been the Owner and Managing Attorney of Stein Legal Offices, where he focuses on commercial litigation but also handles constitutional matters and employment/wages litigation. Previously, he handled civil litigation, commercial litigation, and appeals as Of Counsel (2013-2017) for The Nathanson Law Firm and as an Associate (2004-2013) and Of Counsel (2013-2015) for Kamensky Rubinstein Hochman & Delott, LLP. From 2002 to 2004, he was an Associate at Blau & Bonavich, where he represented customers suing their brokers in arbitration and plaintiffs in employment actions. He is a member of several bar associations, including the Illinois State Bar Association and the Chicago Bar Association.

Mr. Stein is considered to have good legal ability. He has substantial litigation experience in more complex matters in both state courts and before administrative agencies. He is praised for his litigation skills and for his diligence. The Council finds him Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Mr. Alon Stein has been licensed since 2002. Since 2013 he has been the owner of Stein Law Offices focusing on commercial litigation and representation of small to mid-sized businesses. Prior to that, he worked for Kamensky Rubinstein Hochman & Delott, again handing mostly commercial litigation for healthcare practices. He has litigated in federal court as well as neighboring counties and Wisconsin and has served as arbitrator for Cook County. He has written and spoken on legal topics, is a current officer of the Advocates Society, an Assembly Member to the Illinois State Bar Association, and on the Board of Managers for the Decalogue Society.

Attorneys gave positive feedback on his legal knowledge and litigation ability, stating that he has a high degree of knowledge and is a great advocate. He is courteous and respectful to all, with high integrity and diligence. ISBA finds Alon Stein qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Endorsements
Chicago Federation of Labor
International Union of Operating Engineers Local 399
Teamsters Joint Council No. 25
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 134
Teamsters Local 700
United Hellenic Voters of America
------------------------------------------------------

Maria McCarthy - #92


Campaign Website

Bar Association Evaluation Narratives

The Chicago Bar Association says:
Maria McCarthy is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. McCarthy was admitted to practice law in 1989. Ms. McCarthy served as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney for nearly 20 years, where she had more than 65 jury trials, 500 bench trials, and handled 25 appeals. After retiring from the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office, she served for two years as the First Assistant to the Winnebago County State’s Attorney. Currently, Ms. McCarthy has her own law firm handling criminal matters. Additionally, for nearly 20 years, she has taught trial advocacy at two law schools, criminal law and procedure at a community college, and constitutional law to police officers. Ms. McCarthy is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law.
The Chicago Council of Lawyers says:
Maria McCarthy worked early in her career for Freeborn & Peters in Chicago where she defended companies in civil litigation. But she worked as an assistant state’s attorney in the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office for 30 years. From 2009 to 2019, she was Supervisor of the Third Municipal District. Prior to holding that position, she was the Supervisor of the Homicide/Sex Unit in Chicago, the Supervisor of the Domestic Violence Division and was a Deputy Supervisor in the Traffic Division. She subsequently worked as the First Assistant in the Winnebago County State’s Attorney’s Office, where she supervised the Criminal and Civil Bureaus. In 2022, she was appointed Special Prosecutor in murder cases that are pending in Will County.

Maria McCarthy is considered to have good legal ability with substantial litigation experience in both criminal and civil matters. She is reported to have a very good temperament and is praised for her litigation skills. The Council finds her Qualified for the Circuit Court.
The Illinois State Bar Association says:
Ms. Maria McCarthy has been licensed since 1989. Since March 2022, she has been a partner in the firm of McCarthy & Valentini, where her current focus is her appointment as Special Prosecutor and Assistant Special Prosecutor on some criminal post-trial cases pending in Will County. Prior to that, she had been a career prosecutor in Cook County where she rose to be Supervisor of the Third Municipal District (Rolling Meadows) until 2019, when she left, and subsequently became First Assistant at the Winnebago County State’s Attorney office. She has extensive criminal jury and bench trial experience. She has been a speaker and panelist on legal issues and an Adjunct Professor of Trial Advocacy at Northwestern University School of Law and the John Marshall Law School, now known as the University of Illinois Chicago School of Law. She is a member of various bar associations and was the recipient of the Scales of Justice Award in 2019 from the Northwest Suburban Bar Association.

She is considered to have good ability and knowledge of the law by the attorneys contacted during the investigation, with a good temperament and character. ISBA finds Maria McCarthy qualified to be elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County.

Other Bar Association Evaluations

Arab American Bar Association: Recommended

Asian American Bar Association: Recommended

Black Men Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Black Women Lawyers' Association: Recommended

Cook County Bar Association: Recommended

Decalogue Society of Lawyers: Recommended

Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois: Qualified

Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association (LAGBAC): Highly Recommended

Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended

Women's Bar Association of Illinois: Recommended