Angela Munari Petrone withdraws from 7th Subcircuit race

Associate Judge Angela Munari Petrone withdrew yesterday morning from the race for the 7th Subcircuit Rivkin-Carothers vacancy, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections.

Lots of objections in special filing period judicial contests

Tom Courtney withdrew his bid Monday for the countywide Karnezis vacancy. He had filed, in the meantime, you may recall, for the new Johnson vacancy. He faces a challenge to his nominating petitions in that race as well -- but, then, so too does every other candidate in the race -- every other candidate, that is, except the Democratic Party's slated candidate, Sean S. Chaudhuri.

Actually, Courtney faces two separate challenges in his bid to remain a candidate for the Johnson vacancy. John P. Carroll and Peter Martin Kramer likewise face two challenges in that race. Cassandra Goodrum-Burton faces three separate challenges.

A gentleman by the name of John M. Tervanis is the most prolific challenger of candidates in the Johnson race, challenging the candidacies of Courtney, Goodrum-Burton, Carroll, Kramer, Gregory Raymond LaPapa, Mark A. Lyon, and Bonnie Carol McGrath. Omari Prince has filed challenges to the candidacies of Goodrum-Burton and Carolyn J. Gallagher. Steven M. Laduzinsky has filed additional challenges against Goodrum-Burton and Carroll. Ram Villivalam and Ashish Sen have filed additional challenges against Courtney and Kramer.

Most of the candidates for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy in the 5th Subcircuit also drew challenges yesterday, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections -- but not Jameika Mangum or Associate Judge Leonard Murray. Of course, before ascending to the bench, Judge Murray was himself an election lawyer, so the absence of a challenge to his papers should not be considered surprising.

John C. Ervin, Jr. and Terry Ervin have challenged all the other candidates for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy, namely, Daryl Jones, Mary Alice Melchor, H. Yvonne Coleman, Jo Anne Guilemette, and Celestia Mays. Jahesha Nassim has also filed challenges to the candidacies of Melchor, Coleman, Guilemette, and Mays.

Two of the four candidates for the countywide Palmer vacancy have drawn challenges. Deidre Baumann and Camela A. Gardner are the challenged candidates for this vacancy; Gardner faces two challenges. The Democratic Party's slated candidate, Pat Heneghan, and Susana L. Ortiz are the other two candidates in this race.

Both candidates for the Ponce De Leon vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit will have to survive challenges in order to appear on the March primary ballot -- challenges were filed yesterday to the petitions of both Eulalia "Evie" De La Rosa and Richard A. Lugo.

Filing unopposed provides no guarantee against a ballot challenge: James M. Allegretti, who filed unopposed in the Republican primary for the Mathein vacancy in the 12th Subcircuit, and Thomas William Flannigan, who filed unopposed in the Republican primary for the 12th Subcircuit Kazmierski, Jr. vacancy, both drew challenges yesterday afternoon, according to the ISBE. That's not as nutty as it sounds: If the challenges prove successful, the winners of the Democratic Primary will be as good as elected in March.

No challenges were filed against either of the Democratic candidates for the Mathein vacancy. Associate Judge Marguerite Anne Quinn was the only Democratic candidate drawing a challenge for the Kazmierski, Jr. vacancy.

Lots of candidates file on last day -- but not in every race

Ricardo Lugo filed late yesterday afternoon to oppose Eulalia "Evie" DeLaRosa for the Ponce De Leon vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit.

Licensed in Illinois since 2001, Lugo was an Assistant Public Defender in Wisconsin from 1991 to 2000. He currently works for the Clerk of the Circuit Court. Lugo also sought a 6th Subcircuit vacancy in 2012.

No one filed to run against Matthew Link in the 14th Subcircuit -- but, then, no one filed to run against Regina Ann Scannicchio in 2012 either. And Daniel J. Pierce in 2010... and James N. O'Hara and Edward Arce in 2008... and James R. Brown and Lawrence O'Gara in 2002... and Maura Slattery Boyle in 2000 were all elected from the 14th Subcircuit without opposition. (There are those who might consider this a pattern.)

In stark contrast, there are now nine candidates for the countywide Johnson vacancy. Six filed on December 14, the first day of the special filing period. Three more filed yesterday: Cassandra Goodrum-Burton, Bonnie Carol McGrath and John P. Carroll.

South Side practitioner Goodrum-Burton has been licensed in Illinois since 1987. Cassandra Goodrum Burton is a former assistant state's attorney now in private practice; she ran for 6th Ward Alderman in 2011, losing the election but receiving the Tribune's endorsement. Bonnie Carol McGrath is a writer as well as a solo practitioner; her Chicago Now blog, "Mom, I Think I'm Poignant," has been linked from this page for some time. She has been licensed in Illinois since 1993. There are three John P. Carrolls licensed to practice law in Illinois, according to ARDC, and, until I have actual information, I can do no more than report this candidate's name.

There are now four candidates for the countywide Palmer vacancy. Only 'pre-slated' candidate Pat Heneghan filed on December 14. Yesterday, however, Susana L. Ortiz, Deidre Baumann, and Camela A. Gardner all filed; there will be a lottery between Baumann and Gardner to determine who will have the last position in the ballot in this race.

Susana Ortiz has been licensed in Illinois since 2001. She is a staff attorney at the IIT Chicago-Kent Law Offices. Deidre Baumann has been licensed in Illinois since 1992. She practices with the Firm of Baumann and Shuldiner. Camela A. Gardner is an attorney with the Illinois Department of Public Heath; she has been licensed in Illinois since 1989.

Rolling Meadows criminal defense attorney Jameika Mangum was the only candidate to file for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy on December 14 -- but, oh, how that's changed: At the moment, there are seven candidates in this race. I told you yesterday morning that both Associate Judge Leonard Murray and Daryl Jones filed for this vacancy yesterday morning. (Jones filed without withdrawing from the race for the Williams vacancy; according to the ISBE website, he still hasn't).

Subsequently, Mary Alice Melchor filed for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy -- but only after she did withdraw from the Williams vacancy. Also filing yesterday afternoon for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy were H. Yvonne Coleman, Jo Anne Guillemette, and Celestia Mays.

H. Yvonne Coleman filed for a countywide vacancy in the 2014 primary election cycle but withdrew her candidacy; she has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1988. Guillemette was a candidate for a countywide vacancy in 2012. She is an employee of the Chief Judge's office and has served as Assistant Attorney General. Guillemette been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1987. Celestia Mays served as President of the Cook County Bar Association in 2014-15. She maintains a Loop law office where, according to her LinkedIn profile, she handles divorce, child support, custody, visitation and paternity, guardianship and estate matters. Mays has been licensed in Illinois since 1990.

The expansion of the field in the race for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy has resulted in a significant contraction of the field in the race for the 5th Subcircuit Williams vacancy. Judge Robin Denise Shoffner remains in this race, as does Gwendolyn Dale Anderson and (for the time being, anyway) Daryl Jones. Both Anderson and Jones face petition challenges.

Four new candidates filed yesterday in the two new 12th Subcircuit races, two Republicans and two Democrats. I told you yesterday about James Leonard Allegretti, who filed in the Republican primary for the Mathein vacancy. He was the only Republican to file there. Meanwhile, Thomas William Flannigan was the only candidate to file as a Republican candidate for the Kazmierski, Jr. vacancy. Flannigan sought a 12th Subcircuit vacancy in 2008, a countywide vacancy in 2010, and ran for the Illinois Supreme Court in 2012. He has a law office in the Loop.

Both of the candidates filing yesterday as Democrats in the 12th Subcircuit are seeking the Kazmierski, Jr. vacancy. The new candidates are Frank J. Andreou and Jennifer E. Bae. Andreou has an office in the West Loop, practicing with the firm of Andreou & Casson, Ltd. He has been licensed in Illinois since 1995. Jennifer Bae has sought judicial office twice previously, once from the 4th Subcircuit in the 2008 primary and, in the 2012 primary election cycle, from the 12th Subcircuit. (A successful petition challenge kept Bae off the ballot in 2012; her name also did not appear on the ballot in 2008.) Bae has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1997; she practices from a law office in Des Plaines.

On the last day of filing....

Three Cook County judicial candidates filed early this morning for vacancies in the 5th and 12th Subcircuits, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections website.

Daryl Jones, who previously filed for the Williams vacancy in the 5th Subcircuit, filed this morning for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy there. As of the original time of this post, Jones had not yet withdrawn from the contest for the Williams vacancy.

Associate Judge Leonard Murray also filed for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy this morning. Judge Murray was one of the several judges tabbed as "alternate" candidates for the Appellate Court by the Cook County Democratic Party this past summer. Jameika Mangum, who also filed for the Williams vacancy, but withdrew from that race, is the third candidate in the race for the Eadie-Daniels vacancy so far.

On the Republican side, Park Ridge attorney James Leonard Allegretti has filed for the Mathein vacancy. He is so far the only Republican to file for this vacancy. An attorney since 1978, Allegretti practices with the firm of Allegretti & Associates.

December 29 fundraiser planned for Ed Underhill

Supporters of Ed Underhill's campaign for the "A" vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit are planning a holiday fundraiser for their candidate, on Tuesday, December 29, from 5:00 to 7:00 p.m., at the Shamrock Club, 210 West Kinzie, in River North.

Tickets for the event are $100 apiece, but sponsorships are available ($250 - Friend, $500 - Host, or $1,000 - Sponsor). The event is hosted by Kathleen Gaber, Scott Hanson, Julie Hill, Jeff Osman, Gerald Morel and George Kobayashi. For more information about the event, or to order tickets, email Mia Phifer at Mia@miaphifer.com or call her at (773) 398-6986.

So an appointed judge withdraws from the race and we are supposed to believe that no deals were made?

This was the rather angry question asked by an anonymous (what else?) commenter in response to a recent blog post.

Well, sir (or madam), who's asking you to believe that no deals were made?

For the sake of the now-former candidate in question, who, by the way, I do not know, I hope he cut a great deal, complete with solemn promises and maybe even blood oaths of future support.

The particular candidate would not be the first to withdraw in response to a request from the Democratic Party. Not even close. It happens in every election cycle, so far as I know.

And that's if the candidate was in fact requested to step aside. My angry and anonymous commenter dismissed outright the possibility that the candidate may have decided that he did not like being a judge as much as he thought he would. But I couldn't say that for certain. Oddly enough, candidates do not routinely confide in me about such matters. And by routinely, I mean candidates never confide in me about such things. Why should they?

Nor did I speculate on the withdrawing candidate's motives in my post. I wrote -- and this is a fact -- that the candidate would have been running against the Democratic Party and its slated candidate. There may be those in the Party who would not look kindly on a person who runs against their candidate today and then seeks the Party's support in a future race. The slated candidate will have fundraising and other advantages that an unslated candidate, even one who happens to be an appointed judge, would have difficulty matching. In the particular case, the candidate was also facing a challenge to his nominating petitions when he withdrew. Perhaps there was a problem with the petitions. Perhaps the challenge was eminently survivable -- but the cost of fighting to stay on the ballot may have been pretty steep. FWIW readers know how often challenges are filed against judicial candidates. It isn't very nice, but there is nothing illegal, so far as I know, about mounting a ballot challenge against a candidate with an eye toward diverting that candidate's resources from campaigning (assuming, of course, that there is a good faith basis for the challenge in the first place).

And there are other factors a candidate might consider. A candidate might have a partnership to return to while waiting for the next election cycle or a reasonably good expectation of another judicial appointment. There are any number of personal factors that an individual candidate can and should be able to evaluate, with or without the assistance of his or her family and friends, about whether to stay in a race or step aside.

What am I missing? Have I been simmering so long in the cynical cesspool of Cook County politics that, even as a mere observer, my moral compass has been thrown off kilter?

These, by the way, are serious, as opposed to rhetorical, questions.

It seems to me that, since we elect judges in this state, candidates for that office are entitled to take political considerations into account when assessing their chances for success now or in the future and to act accordingly, according to their own best judgment. But that's just my opinion, clearly labeled as such. Readers, what say ye?

Judge Quinn enters 12th Subcircuit race; Judge Cleary pulls out of race for Walsh vacancy

According to the Illinois State Board of Elections, Associate Judge Marguerite Anne Quinn filed this afternoon for the Democratic nomination for the Kazmierski, Jr. in the 12th Judicial Subcircuit. The only other candidate to file in this race is Louis George Apostol. Quinn has been an associate judge since 2007; she sought an Appellate Court vacancy in 2012.

Meanwhile, the race for the countywide Walsh vacancy reconfigured today when Judge Gerald V. Cleary withdrew his candidacy. Cleary had been awarded the top ballot position in this race, but would have been bucking the Democratic Party in pressing his attempt to hold the seat to which he had been appointed by the Illinois Supreme Court. The remaining candidates in this race are the slated candidate, Judge Fredrick H. Bates (recently appointed by the Supreme Court to the Johnson vacancy, but "pre-slated" for this vacancy, when it occurred), Kevin Patrick Cunningham and Patrick Joseph Powers. Powers inherits the top ballot position abandoned by Judge Cleary.

Thomas Francis McGuire withdraws from race for Elrod vacancy

Park Ridge criminal defense attorney Thomas Francis McGuire withdrew this morning from the race for the countywide Elrod vacancy, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections.

McGuire's departure leaves just two candidates in that race, the slated candidate, Judge Rossana Patricia Fernandez, and Scott Edward Lipinski. A fourth candidate, Joseph Chico, withdrew from the race on December 9.

McDonald withdraws from 4th Subcircuit race; Judge King now unopposed

Countryside attorney Donna McDonald has withdrawn from the race for the Democratic nomination for the Kunkle vacancy in the 4th Judicial Subcircuit, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections. Her departure from the race leaves Judge Edward J. King as the only candidate in the race.

No Republican filed for this vacancy.

Judge Jerry Esrig interviewed on NTNM

Judge Jerry Esrig, a candidate for the Berman vacancy in the 9th Judicial Subcircuit, was a recent guest on Avy Meyers' North Town News Magazine program and his interview has been posted online.

NTNM airs Thursdays on CAN-TV at 7:30 p.m., and again on Fridays at 2:30 p.m. It airs in Evanston on Cable Channel 6 on Thursdays at 5:00 p.m. and Sundays at 10:30 p.m. NTNM also airs on a number of cable systems in the suburbs Thursdays and Monday. Check your local listings for air times. Meanwhile, with the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

McQuillen withdraws from 10th Subcircuit race

Assistant State's Attorney Timothy Matthew McQuillen withdrew his candidacy this afternoon for the Howard vacancy in the 10th Judicial Subcircuit, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections.

Five candidates remain in that race after McQuillen's withdrawal, Colleen Reardon Daly, Stephanie Saltouros, Judge Eve Marie Reilly, Michael John Malatesta, and Richard "Rick" Cenar.

Three file for two new vacancies in 12th Subcircuit; Mangum returns in the 5th

Louis George Apostol is the only candidate so far to file in the Democratic Primary for the Kazmierski, Jr. vacancy in the far north suburban 12th Subcircuit. Apostol is the Executive Director, general counsel and legislative liaison for the Illinois Property Tax Appeal Board. As Executive Director, he is responsible for the management and adjudication of all residential, commercial, industrial and farm property tax appeals in Illinois. Licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1980, Apostol previously served as a Commissioner (trial judge) on the Illinois Court of Claims (from 2003-2008) and, from 1991 to 2003, as Public Administrator of Cook County. Apostol was not "pre-slated" for any new 12th Subcircuit vacancies that might occur (as two did) for special judicial filing period but, in September, when reporting the outcome of the 12th Subcircuit slating meeting, FWIW quoted an email from Northfield Township Committeeman Mike Kreloff, Apostol would be "strongly considered" for endorsement.

Two candidates have filed in the Democratic primary so far for the Mathein vacancy in the 12th Subcircuit, Adam Scott Mathein and Janet Cronin Mahoney. Adam Scott Mathein is a principal in the firm of Mathein & Rostoker, P.C.; he has been licensed in Illinois since 1997. Mahoney is an Assistant State's Attorney; she has been licensed in Illinois since 1987.

Rolling Meadows criminal practitioner Jameika Mangum, withdrew her candidacy for the Williams vacancy in the 5th Subcircuit just last Monday. Today, Mangum filed for the new Eadie-Daniels vacancy in the 5th Subcircuit. She is so far the only candidate to file in this race.

De La Rosa files in the 6th Subcircuit; Link in the 14th

Assistant Public Defender Eulalia "Evie" De La Rosa, the Immediate Past President of the Puerto Rican Bar Association of Illinois, is the only candidate so far to file for the Ponce De Leon vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit. De La Rosa has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 2004.

Matthew Link was the only candidate filing for the Murphy vacancy in the 14th Subcircuit when the doors to the ISBE opened this morning. According to ARDC, Link is employed by the Committee on Finance of the City Council of the City of Chicago and has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 2004.

Six candidates file for Johnson vacancy on 1st day of special judicial filing period

Six candidates for the countywide Johnson vacancy were in line this morning when the Illinois State Board of Elections opened its doors for the first day of the special judicial filing period.

The Democratic Party's pre-slated candidate, Sean Chaudhuri, pictured here, was one of these. Gregory Raymond LaPapa, who recently withdrew from the race for the countywide Love vacancy also filed for this vacancy, as did Tom Courtney, who (at last check) has yet to withdraw from the race for the countywide Karnezis vacancy.

Carolyn J. Gallagher is the only female candidate to file for this vacancy so far. The other two candidates filing this morning are Peter Martin Kramer and Mark A. Lyon. According to ARDC, Kramer is employed by the Cook County Sheriff; he has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 2002. Lyon is a DuPage County Assistant Public Defender, according to ARDC; he has been licensed in Illinois since 1986.

Meanwhile, Pat Heneghan is so far the only candidate to file for the countywide Palmer vacancy. Heneghan was pre-slated by the Democratic Party for this newly-opened vacancy.

Judge Carrie Hamilton interviewed on NTNM

Judge Carrie Hamilton, the only candidate for the Democratic nomination for the Tristano vacancy in the 12th Judicial Subcircuit, was a recent guest on Avy Meyers' North Town News Magazine program and her interview has been posted online. Hamilton will face Republican David Studenroth in November 2016.

NTNM airs Thursdays on CAN-TV at 7:30 p.m., and again on Fridays at 2:30 p.m. It airs in Evanston on Cable Channel 6 on Thursdays at 5:00 p.m. and Sundays at 10:30 p.m. NTNM also airs on a number of cable systems in the suburbs Thursdays and Monday. Check your local listings for air times. Meanwhile, with the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

Seven applications accepted for upcoming vacancy on Chicago Electoral Board

Seven applicants have qualified as candidates for the soon-to-be open seat on the Chicago Board of Election Commissioners, Chief Cook County Circuit Judge Timothy C. Evans announced yesterday.

The qualified candidates are (in alphabetical order):

• Robert W. Bertucci, Cook County Circuit Judge;
• Fred Fortier, attorney at Fortier Law Offices and general manager of Galena Development;
• Dick Simpson, political science professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago;
• Thomas E. Soule, attorney;
• Jonathan T. Swain, chairman of the City of Chicago Zoning Board of Appeals and president of Kimbark Beverage Shoppe;
• Betty Tsamis, attorney at Tsamis Law Firm P.C.; and
• Sean Vinck, director of Enterprise IT Transformation and senior legal adviser for the State of Oregon.

Chief Judge Evans will interview all seven candidates and select one candidate to submit to the Circuit Judges of the Cook County Circuit Court for approval. To join the board, the candidate needs the approval of a majority of the Circuit Judges. The interviews will begin Monday, December 14, and the decision of the Circuit Judges is anticipated by the end of December.

FWIW readers may recall that Professor Simpson once served as Alderman of Chicago's 44th Ward (from 1971-1979). The Chicago Reader's Ben Jarovsky has a post up about Simpson's application. Judge Bertucci was first elected from the 14th Subcircuit in 1992; he was most recently retained in 2010.

Under a state statute, the composition of the three-member board is to include one member from the state’s two leading political parties. Currently, the board has one Democrat and one Republican. The current opening is not limited to any political party, but all of these candidates are identified as Democrats.

The current vacancy occurred when Election Board Chairman Langdon D. Neal informed Chief Judge Evans that he would step down at the end of this month. Another vacancy on the Chicago Board of Election Commissioners was filled last month when William J. Kresse was appointed as the Republican commissioner. The third (Democratic) commissioner is Marisel A. Hernandez.

Under state law, vacancies are filled by the Circuit Court where the Election Board is located. The Cook County Board has set Chicago Board of Election Commissioner salaries at $77,798 annually. Commissioners serve three-year terms.

The commissioners manage voter registrations; safeguard the rights of all voters to cast ballots independently in a safe and quiet atmosphere, free of interference or intimidation; and inform voters of all of their balloting options, such as Election Day voting, Early Voting and Vote By Mail.

In addition, the board serves as the quasi-judicial arm of the courts and issues decisions when a voter objects to the nominating petitions of a candidate who wants to be on the Election Day ballot. Such offices include Chicago Mayor, Chicago Alderman, Ward Committeeman, City Treasurer, City Clerk and certain Congressional, Illinois Senate and Illinois House of Representatives Districts that fall partly or entirely in the City of Chicago. The Chicago Board of Election Commissioners does not hear challenges to the nominating petitions of Cook County judicial candidates.

For the current vacancy, the balance of the term will end on November 30, 2017, when Neal’s three-year term would have concluded.

The candidates’ application forms can be found at www.cookcountycourt.org.

David Studenroth campaign website found online

Found on the Internet, the campaign website of David Studenroth, Republican candidate for the Tristano vacancy in the 12th Judicial Subcircuit. That's a link to the candidate's website in the preceding sentence; a link has also been added to the blog Sidebar.

Studenroth has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1987, according to ARDC. According to his campaign biography, Studenroth is a former Assistant State's Attorney who worked as a gang crimes prosecutor. He is now in private practice, and maintains a law office in Park Ridge. He reports trying more than 70 criminal jury cases. According to his campaign biography, Studenroth is a resident of Glenview. He is married and has three children and has served as a coach in the Glenview Junior Titans youth football program and as a boys and girls coach in the Glenview Park District basketball program.

Studenroth faces no opposition in the Republican primary. He will face Judge Carrie Hamilton in November 2016 (Hamilton is unopposed in the Democratic primary).

Colleen Reardon Daly interviewed on NTNM

Colleen Reardon Daly, one of the candidates for the Howard vacancy in the 10th Judicial Subcircuit, was a recent guest on Avy Meyers' North Town News Magazine program and her interview has been posted online.

NTNM airs Thursdays on CAN-TV at 7:30 p.m., and again on Fridays at 2:30 p.m. It airs in Evanston on Cable Channel 6 on Thursdays at 5:00 p.m. and Sundays at 10:30 p.m. NTNM also airs on a number of cable systems in the suburbs Thursdays and Monday. Check your local listings for air times. Meanwhile, with the permission of NTNM host and moderator Avy Meyers and his entire technical crew Sonny Hersh, you can watch the interview here.

Ballot lottery winners and losers

The theory -- and there is statistical evidence to back this up -- is that the top ballot position is worth something in a judicial primary election. The ballot bump varies from election cycle to election cycle, but snagging that top spot means more votes.

Thus, in the race for the "A" vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit, Judge Anna Loftus must be considered a 'winner' for securing the top spot in yesterday's ballot lottery, conducted by the Illinois State Board of Elections. Edward J. Underhill snagged the second spot, while slated candidate Carlos Claudio drew third place. These three candidates were in the lottery because their nominating petitions were deemed filed as soon as the doors opened at the ISBE on the morning of November 23.

Colleen Reardon Daly won the top spot in the race for the Howard vacancy in the 10th Subcircuit. Slated candidate Stephanie Saltouros came in second, while Judge Eve Marie Reilly, who holds the seat pursuant to Supreme Court appointment, came in third. Michael John Malatesta was fourth in the ballot lottery for this seat and Richard "Rick" Cenar came in fifth. The sixth candidate, Timothy Matthew McQuillen, did not file his nominating papers until the last day of the filing period and was therefore not included in the lottery for the top ballot line.

Judge Patricia S. "Pat" Spratt did not need the ballot lottery to maintain the top spot in the race for the Rivkin-Carothers vacancy in that crowded 7th Subcircuit race: She was the only remaining candidate in the field who was counted as in line to file on the first day of filing. (A second lottery-eligible candidate, Brian O'Hara, withdrew from that race in order to seek the countywide Karnezis vacancy.)

O'Hara was also eligible for the lottery for the top ballot position in that countywide race, but he came in third, behind Mary Kathleen McHugh and Judge Devlin J. Schoop. Tom Courtney drew the last spot.

Judge Rossana Patricia Fernandez finished third (of three candidates) in the ballot lottery for the top spot in the race for the countywide Elrod vacancy. Scott Edward Lipinski has the top spot, followed by Thomas Francis McGuire. A fourth candidate in this race, Joseph Chico, withdrew his candidacy yesterday, according to the ISBE.

Michael I. O'Malley holds the top ballot position in his one-on-one challenge against Judge Alison C. Conlon. Both John E. Marszalek, who snagged the top spot, and William Wojcik finished ahead of Judge Daniel Patrick Duffy in the lottery for the top ballot position in the Ruscitti Grussel vacancy. A fourth candidate, Monica M. Torres-Linares was not eligible for that lottery because she filed later.

Judge Gerald V. Cleary won the top spot in the drawing for the top line for the Walsh vacancy. All four candidates were eligible for the lottery in this race. Patrick Joseph Powers and Kevin Patrick Cunningham finished second and third, respectively. Judge Fredrick H. Bates, the slated candidate, finished fourth.

In the 1st Subcircuit, Jesse Outlaw was awarded the top ballot position over Judge Maryam Ahmad in the race for the Brim vacancy. In the Hopkins vacancy, however, Judge Anthony E. Simpkins got the top line over Rhonda Crawford. (The third candidate in that race, Lisa A. Copland, was not eligible for the lottery.)

Celeste K. Jones won the lottery for the top spot in the race to fill the 2nd Subcircuit vacancy. Chelsey R. Robinson and D. Renee Jackson finished second and third, respectively. Travis Richardson was not eligible for the lottery.

Of course, there are challenges pending in many of these races, and the outcome of those proceedings may shake up the ballot order further.

Brendan O'Brien fundraiser set for January 21

Supporters of Brendan O'Brien's campaign for the countywide Love vacancy are holding a fundraiser for their candidate on Thursday, January 21, 2016, from 5:30 to 8:30 p.m., at Moe's Cantina, 155 W. Kinzie.

Wait a minute, you say -- isn't O'Brien unopposed in the primary? Isn't it true that he faces no Republican opposition?

Well, you are correct, the answer to both those questions is 'yes' -- but the campaign necessarily incurred expenses to get to this point. The campaign could not assume that no one would oppose their candidate. So a fundraiser is still needed to defray expenses.

But the ticket price is only $50 per person (a $300 sponsorship is available). Cocktails and food will be served. Hosts for the event are Martin Perez, Mark McKenna, Stephanie Nathanson, John Palumbo, Paul Reidy, Mark Hooper, Dave Gubbins, Dan Trevino, Steve Bonanno, Stan Davidson, Phil Kujawa, Dave Afini, Josh Vincent, and Ted McNabola. For more information, or to order tickets, email nrowell@hinshawlaw.com.

How can you find out what the challenges are?

This was a question raised as a comment to yesterday's post, and it's one I can even answer... up to a point.

Cook County Clerk David Orr maintains a great website (by Cook County standards, that's an understatement -- as everyone who has ever accessed our Circuit Clerk's website will solemnly agree) which lists all the ballot challenges and provides the next public hearing date in each case. Here is the link to the Electoral Board website maintained by the County Clerk's office: http://www.cookcountyclerk.com/elections/electoralboard/Pages/default.aspx.

Each candidate complaint is arranged by office sought -- objections for those seeking Cook County offices, for example are listed CC01, et seq.. All the judicial candidate objections are listed as JUD01, JUD02, JUD03 et seq.

Each docket number has embedded within it a link to the Complaint filed in each case.

Thus, for example, we find, in clicking on the challenge to the petitions of uncontested candidate Maureen O'Donoghue Hannon -- admit it, you were wondering about that one, too -- a single page complaint stating that the "objection is that Maureen O'Donoghue has proven to be an unreasonable States Attorney as demonstrated in her litigation of" one specified case in the Northern District of Illinois and two specified appeals before the 7th Circuit "leading any reasonable person to believe that MAUREEN O'DONOGHUE HANNON would be an unreasonable judge if she were successful in her nomination and possible election to the Court."

Well. Some challenges are more likely to succeed than others -- didn't I tell you that?

But the serious challenges are harder to evaluate, mainly because the appendices to the complaints, where all the real meat of a challenge is usually contained, are not included in the documents posted on line.

Of course, each one of these documents contains the names and addresses of hundreds or even thousands of persons, whether or not they are registered voters, whose privacy should not be disturbed.

So... while you will see the same allegations repeatedly... failed to file the required number of signatures... filed petitions with signatures of persons not registered to vote... signers resided outside district (very popular in subcircuit objections)... used improperly qualified circulators... and although there are certainly exceptions to this rule, it won't necessarily be easy to find out how strong any particular challenge may be until the process unfolds a bit more.

Postscript: Proving once again that I have the best readers on the Internet, while I was preparing this post, someone already provided the link to County Clerk Orr's Electoral Board website in the comments section to the preceding post.

Running for judge in Cook County can be very challenging indeed

Five of the seven remaining candidates for the Rivkin-Carothers vacancy in the 7th Subcircuit will face challenges to their nominating petitions before the Cook County Electoral Board.

Only Judge Patricia "Pat" S. Spratt and Patrick D. John escaped legal challenges to their candidacies. Four of the five challenged candidates, Mable Taylor, Christopher J. Stuart, slated candidate Jennifer Ballard, and Associate Judge Angela Munari Petrone, face two separate challenges to their papers.

All four candidates for the only vacancy in the 2nd Subcircuit face petition challenges. Travis Richardson faces two challenges.

As Finley Peter Dunne said, about 100 years before the creation of judicial subcircuits, "Politics ain't beanbag."

One might be tempted to extrapolate from these data points that crowded races bring multiple challenges -- but, in the crowded race for the sole vacancy in the 10th Subcircuit, only Timothy Matthew McQuillen drew a challenge to his nominating petitions. The other five candidates in that race were not challenged.

In a race that has drawn a great deal of attention, at least on FWIW, the race for the "A" vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit, no candidates' petitions have been challenged.

Thomas Maloney Cushing filed at the last minute for the countywide Howlett, Jr. vacancy, challenging Judge Alexsandra "Alex" Gillespie, who holds the seat pursuant to Supreme Court appointment and is the Democratic Party's slated candidate. Cushing ran in the 9th Subcircuit in 2014 and was, in the estimation of the various bar associations screening candidates in that primary, one of the highest rated candidates anywhere in the county. Neither of these candidates has been challenged.

Nor were any challenges filed in the countywide Hogan vacancy, where Judge Alison C. Conlon has a one-on-one set up with Michael I. O'Malley.

Similarly, neither of the two candidates for the Kunkle vacancy in the 4th Subcircuit, Donna McDonald or Judge Edward J. King, drew any challenges to their nominating petitions. Former Judge Allan W. Masters got knocked off the ballot in 2014 (he fell six signatures short), but his petitions to run for the "A" vacancy in the 12th Subcircuit Democratic Primary in this election cycle have drawn no challenge. Masters' opponent in that race is James Edward Hanlon, Jr., the Democratic Party's slated candidate. Hanlon is likewise unchallenged.

None of the three candidates for the Hopkins vacancy in the 1st Subcircuit, Rhonda Crawford, Lisa A. Copland, or Judge Anthony E. Simpkins, drew any challenge either.

From these data points one might be tempted to conclude that less crowded fields provoke fewer challenges.

But both candidates in the race for the other 1st Subcircuit vacancy, Judge Maryam Ahmad and Jesse Outlaw, face ballot challenges.

The only real conclusion in predicting ballot challenges is one most lawyers can appreciate (and one that too often makes clients cringe): It depends.

In the race for the Williams vacancy, four of the five candidates drew ballot challenges. One, Rolling Meadows criminal practitioner Jameika Mangum, withdrew her candidacy after the challenge was filed. Judge Robin Denise Shoffner was not challenged, but her remaining opponents, Gwendolyn Dale Anderson, Daryl Jones, and Mary Alice Melchor all will have to cope with attacks on their nominating papers.

Two of the four candidates in the race for the Elrod vacancy will face challenges, Thomas Francis McGuire and Scott Edward Lipinski. Joseph Chico and Judge Rossana Patricia Fernandez were not challenged.

Nor was Judge Devlin J. Schoop challenged in his bid to hold the countywide Karzenis vacancy. Each of his opponents, however, Brian J. O'Hara, Tom Courtney, and Mary Kathleen McHugh, will face challenges.

Judge Gerald V. Cleary is the only one of four candidates who has been challenged in the race for the countywide Walsh vacancy. Patrick Joseph Powers, Kevin Patrick Cunningham, and Fredrick H. Bates emerged unscathed from the petition review process.

Nathan Benjamin Myers faces a challenge in the race for the 9th Subcircuit Berman vacancy. Judge Jerry Esrig and Thomas Peter Kougias do not.

Judge Marc Martin and Catherine Ann Schneider do not have to deal with any attacks on their nominating papers, but the third candidate in the race for the Kelly vacancy in the 11th Subcircuit, James DiChristofano, does.

On the Republican side, Richard Montgomery Craig faces a ballot challenge in the race for the "A" vacancy in the 12th Subcircuit. Two of the three Republican candidates for the Fecarotta, Jr. vacancy in the 13th Subcircuit, face challenges, Richard George Karwaczka and Kevin Michael O'Donnell. The third candidate in that race, Gary W. Seyrig does ont.

Not all ballot challenges are created equal. Some seem nothing more than nuisance filings, but (if history is any guide, and it is) several will be found meritorious. All have a throw-everything-up-against-the-wall quality that is surely the product of the haste with which ballot challenges must necessarily be assembled. Whether a challenge has merit or not, defending against it can be expensive. The initial status hearings on these various ballot challenges will be Monday, December 14 at 2:00 p.m.

Carolyn Gallagher fundraiser set for Thursday, December 10

Supporters of Carolyn Gallagher's anticipated countywide judicial bid are planning a fundraiser for their candidate on Thursday, December 10, from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. at Stormy's Tavern and Grille, 1735 Orchard Lane in Northfield.

Tickets for the event are $50 apiece. Sponsorships are available (Silver - $100, Gold - $150). The stated hosts for the fundraiser are Peter J. Janus, Jr. and Alfred L. Knorr. For more information about the event, or to order tickets, contact info@electgallagher.com.

Brian O'Hara withdraws from 7th Subcircuit race; objection filing now underway

River Forest practitioner Brian O'Hara had to choose between staying in the very crowded race for the Rivkin-Carothers vacancy in the 7th Subcircuit or the countywide Karzenis vacancy.

He has today advised the Illinois State Board of Elections that he is withdrawing from the 7th Subcircuit race.

There are three other candidates in the race for the Karzenis vacancy besides O'Hara. Judge Devlin J. Schoop holds the seat pursuant to Supreme Court appointment and is the Democratic Party's slated candidate in this race. Tom Courtney and Mary Kathleen McHugh are also candidates for this vacancy. Courtney, who practices in Palos Heights, filed for the Illinois Supreme Court and an Illinois Appellate Court vacancy in 2012, but withdrew from both races. McHugh has been licensed in Illinois since 1993 and is currently practicing with Parrillo Weiss LLC.

Oak Lawn personal injury attorney William S. Wojcik has drawn a challenge to the nominating petitions he filed in the race for the countywide Ruscitti Grussel vacancy. Judge Daniel Patrick Duffy holds this seat pursuant to Supreme Court appointment; Duffy is also the Democratic Party's slated candidate in this race. Other candidates for the Ruscitti Grussel vacancy are Loop PI attorney John E. Marszalek and Monica M. Torres Linares.

Maureen O'Donoghue Hannon may be unopposed in her bid for the countywide O'Brien vacancy, but a challenge has been filed to her nominating petitions as well. Hannon is the slated candidate and presumably had the benefit of experienced political operatives in preparing and filing her petitions; it will be interesting to see how this challenge fares.

There are -- if history is any guide -- quite a number of petition challenges still to come. FWIW will attempt to keep up with the filings as work requirements permit.

December 8 fundraiser for 7th Subcircuit candidate Jennifer Ballard

Supporters of Jennifer Ballard's quest for the Rivkin-Carothers vacancy in the 7th Subcircuit have scheduled a fundraiser for their candidate on Tuesday, December 8, from 5:00 to 7:00 p.m. at the offices of Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP, 222 N. LaSalle Street.

Tickets for the event are $150 each, but sponsorships are available (Supporter - $250, Ambassador - $500, Champion - $1,000). For more information about the event, or to order tickets, visit this page of Ballard's campaign website or email alysonmiller1207@gmail.com.

One countywide, three subcircuit vacancies open up at the last moment

Justice Stuart E. Palmer, a Circuit Court judge who has been serving on the Illinois Appellate Court pursuant to Supreme Court assignment, has announced his intention to step down, opening a second countywide Circuit Court vacancy for the special filing period which begins on December 14 (the other is the vacancy of Judge Marilyn F. Johnson).

The Illinois State Board of Elections has also posted three new subcircuit vacancies, the 5th Subcircuit vacancy of Judge Loretta Eadie-Daniels, and two vacancies in the 12th Subcircuit, those of Judges Joseph G. Kazmierski, Jr. and Veronica B. Mathein.

Sean Chaudhuri and Patrick Heneghan are the candidates 'pre-slated' by the Democratic Party for the Johnson and Palmer vacancies, respectively.

If you visit the ISBE website to confirm these new vacancies, you may encounter the same difficulty I did in trying to document this story for this post. I saw this announcement on the ISBE website this morning before I'd started my morning coffee --

-- but when I clicked on the link and generated this screen --

-- and then clicked on the link to get the .pdf report -- what should I get but the same old "Vacancies as of November 18" list I'd seen 100 times.

Fortunately, ISBE General Counsel Ken Menzel was able to confirm the new vacancies for me and tell me how to work around the technology issue so I could generate the correct report (I had to open the web page in a different browser -- Chrome, in my case, instead of my usual Firefox). Mr. Menzel was kind enough to say he'd had the same problem, at first, and I bring this up only because some of my readers may have experienced it as well. In any event, my thanks to Mr. Menzel.

Richard C. Cooke, Judges Marianne Jackson, William B. Sullivan, Carrie Hamilton, and Ketki "Kay" Steffen unopposed in their respective subcircuit primary races; contests abound elsewhere

Judges Carrie Hamilton and Ketki "Kay" Steffen will presumably face Republican challengers in November 2016, but no Republican or Democratic challengers appeared to challenge either Richard C. Cooke in his bid for the Santiago vacancy in the 6th Subcircuit, Judge William B. Sullivan in his bid for the Zwick vacancy in the 11th Subcircuit, or Judge Marianne Jackson in her bid to hold the Burrell vacancy in the 7th Subcircuit. Barring something entirely unforeseen, all three will be sworn in for full terms on the first Monday of December 2016.

On the other hand, the race for the Rivkin-Carothers vacancy in the 7th Subcircuit now has eight contestants. It is unlikely that all eight will stay in the race (candidates and their surrogates are going over their opponents' petitions even as you read this, looking for ways to mount ballot challenges) -- one, Brian J. O'Hara, also filed for the countywide Karzenis vacancy and has the option, at least, of choosing the countywide race instead.

For the present, at least, in addition to O'Hara, the race for the Rivkin-Carothers vacancy features Judge Patricia "Pat" S. Spratt, who filed to hold this seat, and slated candidate Jennifer Ballard.

Ballard filed for this vacancy yesterday, as did Christopher J. Stuart and Mable Taylor. All three were noted in a post yesterday afternoon. Three more candidates entered the race at the last moment, and will participate in the lottery for the last line on the ballot.

These three are Rosa Silva, Patrick D. John, and Associate Judge Angela Munari Petrone.

Catherine Ann Schneider

While Judge Sullivan will be unopposed in his 11th Subcircuit race, Judge Marc Martin presently faces two challengers in his bid for the Kelly vacancy in the 11th. Catherine Ann Schneider, a senior attorney for CARPLS, has filed in this race, as has Niles attorney James DiChristifano. Schneider and DiChristifano both have Facebook campaign pages; I've linked to these in the preceding sentence. Schneider has been licensed in Illinois since 1994, DiChristifano since 2004.

A sixth challenger entered the race for the Howard vacancy in the 10th Subcircuit late yesterday afternoon. Assistant State's Attorney Timothy Matthew McQuillen has been licensed in Illinois since 2006, according to ARDC.

Judge Jerry Esrig picked up another challenger in his bid to hold his 9th Subcircuit seat. Nathan Benjamin Myers filed for this vacancy late yesterday; he ran against Judge Esrig in 2014 as well. Thomas Peter Kougias is the other candidate in this race.

Burke, Lampkin unopposed for Appellate Court; three unopposed for countywide Circuit Court vacancies

No one filed to run against Judge Eileen O'Neill Burke and Justice Bertina E. Lampkin in their respective Democratic primary races for the Appellate Court. No Republicans filed at all. Burke and Lampkin are virtually guaranteed full 10 year terms on the Illinois Appellate Court beginning in December 2016.

Three Circuit Court candidates also drew no primary opposition: Judge John Fitzgerald Lyke, Jr., Brendan A. O'Brien, and Maureen O'Donoghue Hannon. There is at least one challenger to the Democratic Party's slated candidate in each of the other six countywide vacancies for which nominating papers have so far been accepted (candidates seeking the Johnson vacancy can not file before December 14) -- but the winners of those contested primary contests will likewise be assured of election in the fall of 2016: Not one Republican filed for any countywide vacancy.

Some two-party system, eh?

To be fair, Democrat vs. Republican contests are likely in both 12th Subcircuit races, and in the 13th Subcircuit.

But these are the only races in which any Republicans filed.

In the 13th, newly appointed Judge Ketki "Kay" Steffen is unopposed for the Democratic nomination for the Fecarotta vacancy, while Republicans Richard George Karwaczka, Gary W. Seyring, and Kevin Michael O'Donnell have filed for the Republican nomination.

In the race for the Tristano vacancy in the 12th Subcircuit, Judge Carrie Hamilton is unopposed for the Democratic nomination, while David Studenroth was the only Republican to file.

In the race for the "A" vacancy in the 12th Subcircuit, there are contests in both party primaries. On the Democratic side, slated candidate James Edward Hanlon, Jr. is set to face former Judge Allan W. Masters. Masters was a candidate in the 12th Subcircuit in 2014 until he was ruled off the ballot. On the Republican side, three candidates have filed: Alex Kaplan, Richard Montgomery Craig and Steven A. Kozicki.

But here is the lesson, and one which FWIW readers must pass along to their less politically-involved friends and neighbors: For the most part, with very few exceptions -- detailed above -- the Democratic Primary is the judicial election. Persons interested in selecting qualified judges in this county have to turn out for the primary or be effectively shut out of the process.